Phillies fan mood — September 16, 2026
28
Not Again
▼ 19 PTS VS. 30-DAY BASELINE (47)
01 · Trend
The last 30 days
100
75
50
25
0
TODAY
APR 19
APR 24
APR 29
MAY 4
MAY 10
MAY 15
MAY 20
MAY 25
MAY 30
JUN 4
JUN 9
JUN 14
JUN 19
JUN 24
JUN 29
JUL 4
JUL 9
JUL 14
JUL 19
JUL 24
JUL 29
AUG 5
AUG 10
AUG 15
AUG 20
AUG 25
AUG 30
SEP 4
SEP 9
SEP 14
SEP 19
SEP 24
SEP 29
OCT 4
↔ swipe to scan the month
Daily score30-day baselineToday
02 · The vibe
How Philly felt about the Phillies, that day
Alarm over Luzardo's injured shoulder has curdled into something darker — a 5-8 September, a bullpen that cannot hold leads, and an offense that mailed it in against a tanking opponent have fans openly questioning whether this team deserves the October it is stumbling toward.
03 · The count
The scoring dimensions
Dimension
Score
Score
Confidence
Results satisfaction
22↓ 20
conf 90
Pitching confidence
35↓ 19
conf 88
Lineup confidence
30↓ 8
conf 85
Health outlook
20↓ 20
conf 92
Manager confidence
32↓ 16
conf 72
Front-office trust
38↓ 14
conf 55
Postseason belief
28↓ 10
conf 78
04 · Cheers & groans
What was working and what was not
-9
Luzardo on IL — Postseason Rotation in Jeopardy
The ace is on the injured list with shoulder inflammation 11 days before the playoffs, and nobody can say with confidence he pitches in the wild-card round — the single most alarming development of the stretch run.
-7
Boland's Collapse and Leverage Bullpen Crisis
Boland has allowed runs in five straight appearances and surrendered four home runs in his last seven innings; with Brad Keller already lost, there is no clear high-leverage option between McFarlane — who was in Double-A two months ago — and Jwan Duran.
-6
Offense Reverts to Worst Habits
Chase rates and strikeout-to-walk ratios have deteriorated sharply since August; the bottom of the lineup went 0-for-15 without a baserunner after the fifth spot, and only Harper and Schwarber carry an above-average OPS-plus on the roster.
-5
Mattingly's Bullpen Decisions Under Fire
First-pitch changeup to a lefty pinch hitter with runners on second and third, McFarlane deployed in low-leverage spots while higher-leverage situations go to a fatiguing Boland — the manager's in-game management is drawing pointed criticism from multiple directions.
-5
Sanchez Fatigue and Rotation Depth Concerns
Sanchez has surrendered 18 hits and 11 runs across his last two starts, his sinker velocity is down from 97 to 94-95, and he now ranks second in innings pitched across the majors — with Luzardo out, a declining Sanchez is the number-two starter heading into October.
05 · In the air
Hot takes from fans, journalists, and loudmouths
*As read by Phan-o-meter
I'm freaking out. Until I know he's going to pitch, until I know it, I'm freaking out.
Podcastscore 12
He has been the best pitcher in Major League Baseball since June 10th. And with October coming, a major, major loss at a terrible, most inopportune time.
Podcastscore 18
They are a tough team to believe in. They don't play inspired baseball. They don't play smart baseball.
Podcastscore 20
If you put a gun to my head and you say, who do you want to give the baseball to in an elimination game right now today? I would give the ball to Aaron Nola before Chris Sanchez.
Podcastscore 30
Hittin' Season and The Phillies Show both alarmed by Luzardo's IL placement, Boland's collapse, and an offense with only two above-average hitters; tempered by residual belief the rotation can still carry a short series.
Fan analystscore 35
WIP hosts and callers openly 'freaking out' over Luzardo; Mattingly's bullpen management questioned, Sanchez's decline dissected, and callers demanding wholesale front-office changes after a loss to an effectively-tanking Nationals squad.
Talk radioscore 22
Single comment captures peak anxiety — questioning whether the Phillies even make the playoffs, not just whether they can advance.
Fan commentsscore 18
06 · At the gate
Attendance
Recent gate, 14-day window
94.8%
-2.6pp vs. 97.4% baseline · 2025 same-calendar-window
Sentiment is what people say; the gate is what they do. Capacity is 42,901 at Citizens Bank Park; the baseline compares against 30 games from last year's same calendar window.
| Date | Opponent | Result | Attendance | % Cap. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SEP 10 THU | vs. HOU | L 1-2 | 37,100 | 86.5% |
| SEP 9 WED | vs. HOU | W 11-7 | 38,642 | 90.1% |
| SEP 8 TUE | vs. HOU | L 5-6 | 39,262 | 91.5% |
| SEP 7 MON | vs. ATL | W 1-0 | 41,820 | 97.5% |
| SEP 6 SUN | vs. ATL | L 4-5 | 42,793 | 99.7% |
| SEP 5 SAT | vs. ATL | W 4-2 | 43,241 | 100.8% |
| SEP 4 FRI | vs. ATL | L 2-5 | 41,883 | 97.6% |